Safety culture, dangerous goods procedures lead to injury, dismissal and reinstatement

10 November, 2026

One Minute Summary

  • The delivery driver dropped a dangerous goods container and suffered sulphuric acid burns to his leg. Two other employees also suffered burns after being instructed by the depot supervisor to clean up the spill.
  • After an investigation the delivery driver was terminated for serious misconduct approximately10 weeks later even though he was not directly responsible for the other employee’s injuries.
  • The Commission found that there was a valid reason for the termination but then highlighted a number of issues that made the termination harsh and disproportionate.
  • This included the actions of the supervisor instructing the employees, the general safety culture of the workplace and procedures around loading dangerous goods.
  • The employee was reinstated back into his previous role but did not receive back pay between the date of dismissal and reinstatement.

Mr Egan, 57, a leading hand delivery driver, had been employed by Fedex from December 2020 until his termination on 28 January 2026. He was summarily dismissed for serious misconduct after an incident on 10 November 2025 where he, and several other employees, suffered moderately serious sulphuric acid burns after he dropped a package containing glass acid containers in the back of his truck while loading at a depot near Wollongong.

The subsequent investigation found Mr Egan had caused the incident by dropping the package in breach of manual handling policies and then failed to respond to the spill in accordance with Fedex’s safety procedures. Mr Egan was allowed to continue working between the incident and the termination while the investigation took place.

During Fair Work unfair dismissal proceedings there was no dispute that Mr Egan had dropped the box but there was some contention about the height from which it was dropped on to the truck floor – Mr Egan claiming it was only two inches.

Mr Egan had also failed to identify that the package was a dangerous good containing glass – despite it being clearly labelled as such. He stated that if he had been aware of it he would have handled it with care.

The investigation also found that once he became aware of the spill, including a burning sensation on one of his legs, Mr Egan did not check the labelling and therefore did not respond consistent with safety procedures. However, he quickly escalated the incident to Mr Bates at the depot. Mr Bates, did not check the label or assess the spill before instructing two other employees to clean it up. These employees suffered acid burns during the clean-up.

Commissioner Crawford stated

‘I find there was a valid reason for Mr Egan’s dismissal related to his conduct. Mr Egan did not comply with FedEx’s package handling procedures on 10 November 2025. Mr Egan also failed to identify that the package contained dangerous goods and glass despite clear labels on the package. Mr Egan held a senior position as a Leading Hand Delivery Driver and was expected to set an example for other employees. Mr Egan’s failure to follow FedEx’s safety procedures on 10 November 2025 constitutes a valid reason for dismissal.’   

Thereafter Commissioner Crawford made a number of useful observations:

  • Mr Egan was suffering from a degree of shock and pain immediately after the incident and would not have thought clearly about identifying the contents from the label and warning other employees.
  • Mr Egan could not be held responsible for the injuries sustained for the two other employees who suffered acid burns. Mr Bates was responsible but no disciplinary processes had been brought against him despite not checking the package and following safe clean up procedures: ‘I consider Mr Egan was treated less favourably than Mr Bates when their conduct was reasonably comparable. I consider it would have been reasonable for Mr Egan to also receive a first and final warning letter.’
  • Fedex’s package handling and safety procedures were not being followed by employees at the depot. Video footage showed packages being thrown and kicked and employees climbing on and over conveyors. The rules were regularly breached by employees which was contrary to Fedex’s stated policy and procedures and regular employee training.  The decision stated: ‘It is also clear that other employees have not been subjected to any disciplinary action for breaching package handling procedures and other safety procedures.’
  • After the incident Fedex changed its practices so that drivers now pick up dangerous goods from the dangerous goods storage area rather than have those goods lined up near the truck to be loaded along with all the other packages. This would obviously alert the driver to handle those goods with more care. The Commissioner stated it was unlikely the spill would have occurred if this had been the practice at the time of the incident.
  • The Commissioner acknowledged Mr Egan had experienced financial pressure following his dismissal and had not been able to find secure permanent work with comparable earnings. He noted in the decision Mr Egan was 57 years of age and supported his 14-year-old daughter who had a disability.
  • The Commissioner looked at Mr Egan’s service finding the following: ‘I find Mr Egan’s length of service and disciplinary history are relevant matters. Mr Egan had around five years of service when he was dismissed. That is a medium-term length of employment. Mr Egan had previously been warned for not handling packages appropriately on 19 December 2023.

The Decision found that there was a valid reason for Mr Egan’s dismissal but stated that the termination was unfair as it was harsh and disproportionate. This was based on the above factors and is best summarised by the following points from the decision:

  • the moderate gravity of Mr Egan’s misconduct
  • the differential treatment of Mr Egan and Mr Bates
  • the safety culture at the depot
  • Mr Egan’s personal circumstances

Mr Egan was reinstated to his previous role with Fedex.   The Commissioner decided that due to his misconduct he would not Order payment of the lost salary between the date of dismissal and reinstatement. However, given that Fedex had terminated Mr Egan summarily the Commission required that he be paid 5 weeks – the notice he should have received at the time of termination.

Commentary

It quickly became obvious from the decision that the Commissioner found the employer  response to Mr Egan and Mr Bates quite inconsistent. Mr Egan could not be held responsible for Mr Bates actions when the other two employees were injured. Mr Bates made no attempt to assess the nature of the spill before instructing those employees to clean it up.

This incident occurred in a very questionable safety culture at the depot. Fedex stated it had appropriate policies and trained employees on safe package handling at the site, but this was not evident in video footage shown at the hearing.

After the incident Fedex changed its dangerous goods handling, requiring drivers to pick up a dangerous good from a specific area. I can imagine the pressure on drivers to load their trucks and having standard goods and dangerous goods waiting to be loaded together sounds like an accident waiting to happen.

If you take the above points together making Mr Egan solely responsible was unfair.

What was lacking in this decision, but often becomes in important issue in such cases, is what training Mr Egan had received on handling dangerous goods and responding to a spill. It’s one thing having procedures but when someone is injured and not exactly thinking clearly having practiced a response in a practical sense is more likely to have been remembered than what they read in a procedure some time ago.

I dealt with a safety investigation recently where the employees had been trained about 18 months prior but had largely forgotten the required spill response.  What’s become apparent from prior cases is that if an employer considers a procedure to be important then re-training should take place every 12 months -because human beings forget. If you get much beyond 12 months it becomes very hard for an employer to rely on training in their defence.

Employers seeking assistance with workplace investigations, guidance on potential disciplinary responses, or responding to Fair Work applications from former employees should contact Hunter Employee Relations.

Kind Regards

Michael Schmidt

M 0438 129 728

[email protected]

www.hunteremployeerelations.com.au

Guiding senior managers through complex employee relations issues

Sign up here to receive Hunter Employee Relations Update directly to your email inbox

Want to know more about our client services?

Want to know more about Hunter Employee Relations? 

Keep up to date

Hunter Employee Relations regularly sends out updates on important Fair Work and Court decisions as well as Government initiatives.

Subscribers will receive a complimentary copy of Hunter Employee Relations Employer Guide to Workplace Bullying, Harassment & Discrimination.

Essential reading for all senior management, this user-friendly guide deals with:

  • Identifying bullying, harassment (including sexual harassment) and discrimination
  • Understanding an employer’s legal obligations and liability
  • How to respond appropriately
  • The new positive prevention duty on all employers.