One Minute Summary
- A retail employee physically tackles a shoplifter away from the store while on a break.
- They are denied a support person during the suspension meeting and not provided with a suspension letter. They are told not to attend the store during suspension.
- They return to the store seeking a copy of the script used to suspend them.
- After an investigation the employee is terminated for serious misconduct for two reasons: breaching the employers policy on responding to shoplifters, and for attending the store while suspended.
- The FWC finds there was a valid reason for the termination – the policy exists for the safety of employees. But finds the dismissal harsh and unreasonable because the employee believed, that because they were away from the workplace, the policy did not apply to them and because of the employee’s long unblemished service. The employee is awarded 15 weeks pay less 10% deduction for misconduct.
After two young female shoplifters walked out of the Pyrmont Sydney store abusing staff and taking items with them, Mr Anderson, who had been working at the store as a casual for 10 years and had seen the same girls steal multiple times before, decided to take his break and followed them outside the store. He talked to them and asked them to stop stealing from the store. The girls then went next door to Liquorland and commenced taking items off the shelves and placing them into a bag. The Liquorland shop attendant did not say anything or attempt to stop them but called the Police. Mr Anderson attempted to restrain one of the suspected shoplifters holding them around the shoulders and upper body. Security video showed this occurred for approximately 2mins 20seconds. When he realised the Police would not arrive for some time, he let the girl go. The Police arrived several hours later.
On 3 December 2025, two days after the incident took place, Mr Anderson was asked to attend a meeting (without notice) about the incident by the Store Manager – Ms Stronach. On his requesting a support person this was denied. However, Ms Stronach had arranged for the Deputy Store Manager to be present as her support person. The Store Manager read from a script and suspended Mr Anderson pending an investigation. She informed him he was not to attend the store while suspended. Mr Anderson requested a copy of the script read by Ms Stronach, but this was denied. No letter was issued.
The usual process when a store employee was involved in an altercation with a customer was to suspend the employee pending an investigation.
On 4 December 2025, Mr Anderson, together with a union representative, entered the store and asked to speak to the Store Manager. They requested a copy of the suspension script she had used. Ms Stronach at first denied him the script and threatened to call the Police. After calling a senior manager she provided Mr Anderson with the suspension discussion script and he left the store. Ms Stronach later stated that ‘she felt very shaken and taken aback about what happened’.
On 10 December 2025, Mr Anderson, accompanied by the union representative, attended the store following an email on 8 December which outlined the allegations and advised that due to their serious nature, termination of employment may be considered.
The meeting outlined the allegations and replayed the Liquorland incident video. Mr Anderson was asked to respond but requested further time to prepare a written response. After consulting with a senior manager on the phone another meeting was scheduled for the following day.
On 11 December, after reviewing Mr Anderson’s response, a decision was made to summarily dismiss his employment for serious misconduct based on the incident at Liquorland and for Mr Anderson entering the store while suspended.
During proceedings before Deputy President Wright, Coles gave evidence of its Threatening Situations SWP (Safe Work Practices) and the Coles’ Code of Conduct and how it applied to Mr Anderson’s conduct. The Threatening Situations SWP was written after a Coles staff member had been seriously injured following a similar intervention with a shoplifter. Mr Anderson breached the following sections of the Threatening Situations SWP:
- avoid putting yourself in a situation where you could be hurt;
- always keep a safe distance from an aggressor; and
- never follow anyone out of a shop.
Mr Anderson had completed the Threatening Situations training in October 2025. The training instructs team members to de-escalate the situation and to walk away. It was stated the incident involving Mr Anderson had been one of the most severe breaches of the SWP. Mr Anderson also breached the Code of Conduct by putting himself and others at risk. Mr Anderson attending the store while suspended was a further breach of the Code of Conduct.
Coles stated that in coming to a decision to terminate, Mr Anderson’s length of unblemished service had been taken into account but that it was left with no other option due to his not showing any accountability for what happened.
In her deliberations DP Wright stated that there was no dispute about the incident taking place in the Liquorland store and that the Threatening Situations SWP would have applied had the incident occurred in a Coles store rather than at Liquorland. What was in dispute was firstly, whether Mr Anderson had taken a break when he did in pursuit of the suspected shoplifters following them into the Liquorland store, and secondly, whether the Threatening Situations SWP applied to the situation given Mr Anderson’s claim that he was on a break at the time of the physical altercation.
Mr Anderson stated he took a break immediately after the shoplifters had left the Coles store due to frustration and not to follow them. The CCTV showed him engaging with them in conversation for about 45 seconds before they left and walked towards the Liquorland store. Thereafter he followed them into the store asking them not to steal at Liquorland but they ignored him.
In the decision the DP stated, ‘it seems unlikely that Mr Anderson was on a break at the time of the incident given he had only worked one hour of his six-hour shift. However, in the absence of evidence to the contrary, I accept Mr Anderson’s evidence that he was on a break at the time of the incident.’
In respect to following the shoplifters into Liquorland, the DP stated, ‘…it seems that Mr Anderson intended to monitor the alleged shoplifters so that they could not engage in further theft and that his actions in going into Liquorland were to ensure that this was the case.’
The DP then stated, ‘I accept that Mr Anderson held a genuine belief that the Threatening Situations SWP and the Code of Conduct did not apply because he was in Liquorland and taking a break at the time of the incident. If he had not held this belief, it is unlikely that he would have put his employment at risk and physically restrained the suspected shoplifter. Mr Anderson has never had an altercation with a shoplifter in Coles despite having concerns about high incidences of shoplifting.’
The Deputy President disagreed stating, ‘when the purpose of the Threatening Situations SWP is examined, it is simply not possible to conclude that it would not apply to the situation that Mr Anderson found himself in in Liquorland.’
‘The Threatening Situations SWP is directed towards the safety consequences of attempting to stop theft which can include aggression or physical or verbal abuse resulting in physical or psychological injury. These safety consequences apply regardless of whether a Coles employee attempts to stop a theft within a Coles store or at another location.’
The Deputy President then found that restraining the shoplifter was in breach of the Threatening Situations SWP and the Code of Conduct and that Coles therefore had a valid reason to terminate Mr Anderson’s employment based on his conduct.
‘I do not accept Coles’ characterisation of Mr Anderson’s conduct as serious misconduct, but I accept that it amounted to misconduct.’
In respect to the Mr Anderson breaching the instruction not to attend the workplace while suspended, the DP stated that this needed to be viewed in the context of how Mr Anderson was suspended. This included the denial of a support person even though the manager had a support person present, not giving Mr Anderson a copy of the script as well as the lack of a suspension letter. It was not clear to Mr Anderson that entering the store while suspended would be a case of serious misconduct and therefore did not amount to a valid reason for dismissal.
On taking into account:
- Mr Anderson’s lengthy period of service with Coles;
- Mr Anderson’s good employment record;
- The events of 1 December 2025 being a ‘one off’, isolated incident; and
- Mr Anderson did not knowingly or deliberately breach Coles’ policies on 1 December 2025.
the Deputy President considered the termination to be harsh and unreasonable.
As reinstatement was not considered appropriate Mr Anderson was award 15 weeks pay less 10% for the misconduct.
Commentary
While this may have occurred in a retail environment there are a number of takeaway learnings from this case.
Employers need to review some of their key policies, particularly their Code of Conduct, as to whether they should state they apply beyond the boundaries of the immediate workplace. This will be a case-by-case decision based on the nature of the business.
A comprehensive Code of Conduct is a very useful HR tool and can be the foundation of any behaviour counselling or a disciplinary process.
Attending the workplace during a suspension will in most cases not result in a valid reason for a misconduct (or ‘serious misconduct’) termination. In limited cases it may.
Where an employee asks for a support person this needs to be taken seriously. The Fair Work Act states this cannot be denied on request.
When reading the Decision I was left with the impression of a lack of skill at various levels in the organisation as well as the inability to make a decision. Perhaps as organisations get too large this becomes too complicated to manage?
Although not addressed in detail above the post investigation ‘Show Cause’ process was lacking in this case. It is vital for employers to not trip up on this step.
Above all, while there may be an initial valid reason to terminate based on an incident, each situation must be examined from a number of angles such as length of service etc. The Fair Work Commission routinely issues decisions stating that while an incident provided a valid reason for termination a range of surrounding factors can make that decision harsh or unreasonable – and expensive.
Employers seeking assistance with disciplinary processes, potential terminations or dealing with the resulting unfair dismissal should contact Hunter Employee Relations.
Hunter Employee Relations undertakes workplace investigations for misconduct, safety breaches or workplace culture issues.
Kind Regards
Michael Schmidt
M 0438 129 728
www.hunteremployeerelations.com.au
Guiding senior managers through complex employee relations issues
Sign up here to receive Hunter Employee Relations Update directly to your email inbox
Want to know more about our client services?
Want to know more about Hunter Employee Relations?